Review of the Olympus P-400 Printer
Dye-sublimation printers have always occupied
a relatively small niche in the digital photo printer marketplace. The
undeniable beauty of their true continuous-tone prints has been offset
by the printers' painfully high price tags. The few models available for
under $1,000 could only make small prints (typically about 3 x 5"), and
the ones that could make 8 x 10" prints cost $3,000 or more. Olympus has
changed all that with their new P-400, a high-quality dye-sub printer able
to make prints up to 7.25 x 10" and priced at $999. We think it will appeal
to many quality-conscious digital photographers.
Continuous-Tone
The inkjet printers most of us are familiar
with create the illusion of continuous color and tonal gradation by laying
down a complicated pattern of thousands or millions of separate cyan, magenta,
and yellow ink droplets of uniform intensity.
Dye-sublimation printers, on the other hand,
use three separate passes of a thermal print head to diffuse a tiny gas
cloud of cyan, magenta, and yellow dye from a ribbon onto the printing
paper at each pixel location. This process lets the printer vary the intensity
of each primary color from pixel to pixel and also causes the dyes to physically
mix together. The result is a true continuous-tone color print.
The benefits of the dye-sublimation process
are clearly visible in the P-400's prints. They have a rich, natural, smooth
color quality that can't quite be matched by even the best inkjets currently
available. (Though some of the latter, depending on the image being printed,
sometimes come impressively close.) The P-400 does especially well with
skin tones and in areas of an image where gradual and subtle changes in
color and tonality occur. We were also pleased with the excellent sharpness
and detail of our test prints. (We should note that you can't make meaningful
comparisons between dye-sub and inkjet resolution figures. A good 300-dpi
dye-sub will usually make smoother, more detailed prints than inkjets rated
at 1,000-dpi or more.)
Our one significant complaint is that sharply
defined lines, especially curved ones, sometimes print with a noticeable
jaggyness. This problem is greatly reduced if you set a picture's image
resolution to exactly 314-dpi—no higher, no lower—but the printer's
driver software should do a better job of resampling.
Olympus says the P-400's prints should last
about 15-20 years before showing any color fading. That figure is valid
for more-or-less standard exhibition conditions -- i.e. framed behind UV-protective
glass, kept out of direct sunlight, and protected from aerosols, toxic
gasses, smoke, diesel fumes, petrochemical clouds, volcanic ash, nuclear
fallout, or similar hazards.
Dye, Paper, and Software
You can connect the P-400 to a Mac or PC via
USB. It'll also work with a PC's parallel port, but neither USB nor parallel
cables ship with the printer.
At present, only Olympus offers paper and
dye ribbon for the P-400. The paper costs a dollar per A4 sheet, and you
use 90 cents worth of ribbon every time you make a print regardless of
the actual printed size of the image.
The P-400's driver software includes settings
for sharpening and color adjustment and the option to manage color with
ICC profiles. (Olympus does not provide an ICC profile with the printer.)
The default color adjustment settings on our unit produced color prints
that were a bit too red/orange, but it was relatively easy to find a single
setting that corrected for that tendency in most of our images. (Plus one
unit on the blue gamma slider, for you curious types.) We feel, however,
that the scale of adjustment on the various color settings is a bit too
coarse; for example, moving the red brightness slider by only one unit
produces a fairly dramatic change in the print.
It's probably unfair of us to ask anything
different from a printer with no black dye, but we were mildly disappointed
that we couldn't get the P-400 to produce consistently neutral grays in
our black and white photos. (We could get bluish-gray or greenish-gray
but not grayish-gray.) Still, the bluish-gray prints weren't too far from
neutral and had a beautiful, very smooth tonality.
One thing that's not disappointing is the
P-400's speed; it'll print a 20 megabyte file in 90 seconds (excluding
data compilation time, which varies with your computer.)
No Computer Necessary
Like many newer printers, the P-400 can work
without a computer, making prints directly from SmartMedia or CompactFlash
cards. Using a 16-level grayscale LCD mounted on the P-400's top panel,
you can select which pictures to print, crop them, rotate them, attach
a background image or a border to each one, adjust color and sharpness,
gang six photos onto one sheet of paper, print a thumbnail index sheet,
and more. It's an admirably complete set of features, but navigating the
endless menus necessary to accomplish these tasks is a painful chore that
we don't think many people will want to endure. Further, many images are
impossible to identify on the grayscale LCD.
Overall, we think the P-400 fits a worthwhile
niche. Though more expensive than a good inkjet, it produces a richer,
smoother color print with most images. On the other side of the coin, you
can find dye-subs that make better prints, but you have to spend 3 to 5
times as much to own one.
© 2001 Imagine Media, Inc.
|